Skip to content

It’s Not Just About The Gore: 7 Screenwriting Lessons From SAW (2004)

Saw (2004): Halloween Case Study

Many writers believe Horror is really about gore. Nope! So let me demonstrate with one of the biggest gore fests of all time, Saw (2004).

The set-up of this indie horror movie is deceptively simple: Two men. One filthy bathroom. A corpse between them. Yikes.

As high-concept horror premises go, Saw takes some beating. But if your takeaway is ‘chain some characters to pipes and make them suffer’, you’re missing what makes the story actually work!

For this B2W Halloween case study, I want to look at the craft underneath the carnage: structure, misdirection and moral pressure. Because the bathroom is the trap. What the characters bring INTO it fuels the story.

Spoilers for the whole of Saw (2004), including THAT ending. Obviously. Oh and while we’re here – don’t forget this iconic movie started as a short film first. Check out my previous case study for Saw 0.5 (2003), here.

1) The premise creates conflict immediately

There’s a minimal cast in Saw (2004). We begin with Adam and Dr Lawrence Gordon waking up, chained at opposite ends of a bathroom. Neither knows how he got there.

That’s bad enough, but then the tapes left behind introduce the rules … Gordon must kill Adam by 6pm or his wife and daughter will die. (Lovely. No pressure, then!).

This is a cracking dramatic situation because cooperation and survival are immediately at odds. The men need each other’s help, but one has been instructed to murder the other.

It also immediately makes the viewer ask themselves what they would do – an excellent example of a dramatic hook.  The location does more than contain the action. It forces a relationship neither character would choose.

B2W TAKEAWAY: Don’t stop at ‘they cannot escape’. Ask what makes being trapped TOGETHER unbearable.

2) The investigation teaches us how to watch

The bathroom gives us immediate jeopardy. The police investigation gives us a framework for understanding it – not least the psychopath Behind It All, Jigsaw.

Through Detectives Tapp and Sing, we learn about his previous victims. We also learn about Jigsaw’s methods and his obsession with making people ‘appreciate’ their lives.

This is important exposition, but it’s never ‘just’ spoon-fed to us. The police investigation is active, becoming the audience’s instruction manual. It teaches us to look for patterns, suspect motives and question what counts as escape.

But the investigation also steers us towards particular explanations. We start trying to solve the case alongside the police, which makes their assumptions useful tools for misdirection.

B2W TAKEAWAY: If you have an investigation alongside a survival story, make each strand change how we understand the other. Otherwise, you risk cutting away from the interesting bit for some cops to explain things we already know. Yawn.

3) Information should make the situation worse

Writers frequently treat revelations as answers. A character discovers something, so now they can solve the problem.

In Saw, revelations often create a nastier problem. For example, Adam has been paid to spy on Gordon. Meanwhile, Gordon has been lying about his private life. Neither man has given the other the whole picture.

Their histories are already tangled together. And once that becomes clear, cooperation gets harder. This is why backstory works here. It changes the present conflict.

You can give your character the most elaborate history imaginable. If it never affects what they do, what they conceal or whom they trust, it’s taking up extraneous room.

B2W TAKEAWAY: Look at each revelation and ask, ‘What becomes more difficult because they know this now?’

4) Authority offers false reassurance

Gordon is a doctor. He sounds rational and knows how to assess a situation. Adam is frightened, sarcastic and considerably less polished. It’s easy to assume Gordon is the ‘good’ guy here.

But professional competence cannot give Gordon control over a system somebody else has designed. His authority buys him credibility with Adam and the audience. It cannot buy him his freedom.

The police strand develops the same pressure differently. Sing’s death shows that getting close to Jigsaw does not mean you understand the danger. Tapp’s pursuit becomes an obsession, narrowing his judgement.

These characters have knowledge and experience. The horror comes from discovering their limits.

B2W TAKEAWAY: Establish why somebody ‘deserves’ to be trusted. Then put them in a situation where their usual methods are inadequate.

5) Character arcs need a physical expression

Gordon starts from emotional detachment. By the climax, concern for his family drives him to an appalling physical sacrifice: he cuts off his foot. YOWSER!

You can SEE the distance between the man he was and the man he becomes. That is why the action has dramatic weight. His fear and desperation have been building towards a choice he could scarcely have imagined making at the beginning.

Adam’s trajectory offers a different kind of horror. His understanding grows, but understanding does not guarantee escape.

Best of all, Alison is not some damsel in distress. She is waaaay more than a hostage waiting for the men to sort everything out. Her resistance matters to the action outside the bathroom.

B2W TAKEAWAY: Give internal pressure an external consequence. What does your character actually DO that shows us where they have ended up?

6) The apparent villain creates a false victory

Zep appears to be Behind It All. He is holding Gordon’s family hostage. Tapp pursues him. Adam kills him. Surely we have reached the end of the game? Nope again!!

The tape Adam finds reveals that Zep has also been coerced. He has been poisoned and is following instructions to obtain an antidote. The man who appeared to control the situation was operating under somebody else’s rules.

This revelation changes Zep’s role without erasing what he has done. That’s even more useful misdirection. The behaviour we witnessed remains real, but our understanding of its cause changes.

B2W TAKEAWAY: A red herring needs credible actions and motives. ‘Surprise suckers, it was someone else!’ will not rescue a twist you haven’t built. Set up and pay off is everything.

7) The final reveal changes the whole room

The corpse stands up … Jigsaw has been there all along. Holy shit. WTAF to the max. (Yes, we know this now over twenty years later … but you have to understand what a big deal this was at the time).

The bathroom contains the answer from the beginning. We have looked straight at it, repeatedly. This is classic ‘hiding in plain sight’ – and yes, it’s as difficult to pull off as you think.

The reveal changes our understanding of the space. What looked like evidence of an earlier death becomes the presence of the person controlling the ordeal. There is also a cruel complication: Adam’s key went down the bath drain when he woke. He DOES fight back, yet remains trapped.

So I wouldn’t reduce the ending to ‘Gordon acts and lives; Adam hesitates and dies’. The first film leaves Gordon’s eventual fate unresolved, while Adam’s actions cannot overcome the conditions imposed on him.

Jigsaw presents his games as moral lessons. We don’t have to condone those lessons. For me, that tension makes the ending more disturbing. A killer claiming to value life has appointed himself judge of who deserves it.

B2W TAKEAWAY: Make the twist change the meaning of what we have already seen. Then check that your thematic reading accounts for the awkward details as well as the convenient ones.

What writers can learn from Saw (2004)

The bathroom supplies confinement. The investigation supplies context and suspicion. The characters supply secrets, mistrust and competing priorities. Together, these keep tightening the pressure.

That’s what I’d take from Saw for a contained horror spec. Build a situation where every discovery affects a relationship, every relationship affects a choice, and every choice has a cost.

Then make us believe the ordeal is over … BEFORE you turn out the lights.

Want to read the screenplay? CLICK HERE.

Happy Halloween!

Want Even MORE Horror Tips This Halloween?

Got a horror idea you keep promising yourself you’ll write? Time to drag it into the light with Horrorcon!

Horrorcon with B2W is for novelists, screenwriters and anyone who wants a deep dive into what makes this genre tick. We’ll break down horror movies, uncover the patterns, conventions and tropes behind the scares, then apply that knowledge to our own ideas.

How do you build dread? Make familiar threats feel fresh? Deliver a payoff that gets under your audience’s skin? We’ll explore the choices behind effective horror so you can make them your own.

Horror is my speciality. As a script editor, author and writing coach, I can help you spot what gives your idea its bite and develop it into a story that delivers.

We start on 2 November, 2026. Stop leaving your darkest ideas for “someday”. Only a few places left!

CLICK HERE to book your place at Horrorcon with B2W now, or email me on Bang2write@gmail.com.

Share this:

1 thought on “It’s Not Just About The Gore: 7 Screenwriting Lessons From SAW (2004)”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *