Pretentious? Good. I Hope So!
Right, let’s talk about the P-word: pretentious. It’s the favourite hand grenade of the internet comment section and the pub bore alike. Yawn.
Someone makes a short film that isn’t wall-to-wall car chases? Pretentious. A novelist uses too many long sentences? Pretentious. A singer wears something other than jeans and a T-shirt? Call the Taste Police immediately.
I was noodling around Facebook recently and came across this post. It grabbed my attention immediately, because it’s true.
Check it out …
There is no such thing as “good taste”
NEWSFLASH: there’s only your taste … or mine. Taste isn’t a law of physics. It’s a wardrobe you’ve cobbled together from everything you’ve ever loved, envied or secretly nicked from someone cooler.
So when people go after a creative for being “pretentious”, they’re not handing down a verdict from Mount Culture. They’re just telling us what makes them uncomfortable.
Discomfort is interesting. It’s usually where the good stuff lives
I work with writers all the time who are terrified of being called this word. They file down anything spiky in their stories in case someone on Twitter calls them up themselves.
These writers apologise for ambition before they’ve even written FADE IN. That’s heartbreaking. Because the minute you start creating to avoid an insult, you’ve already lost the game.
Accusing someone of pretension sounds tough, but it’s lazy. It’s a way of shutting down a conversation without engaging with the idea. ‘I don’t get it, therefore it’s rubbish.’
Cool, but that tells me nothing about the art and a lot about the accuser’s boundaries.
Imagine if culture actually obeyed these self-appointed bouncers (Ugh)
We’d be living in a world of that permanent beige: sensible rom-coms, polite crime dramas, songs that never use a weird chord. No Bowie, no Fleabag, no bonkers student films shot in a shed that accidentally invent a new genre.
The truth is, most of what gets called pretentious is just enthusiasm without shame. Someone cared enough to try something big. Maybe these creatives missed the mark. So what? I’d rather watch a messy swing for the fences than another perfectly “tasteful” bunt.
(And spare me the ‘B-B-But Hollywood is risk-averse!’ BS. That’s a different argument, which I’ve written about on this blog before, HERE).
So, I’m done treating pretentious as an insult
If a piece of work is reaching, dreaming, wobbling around in high heels it can’t quite walk in … good. I say let it!!!
The only thing worse than bad art is art too scared to exist. Bring on the oddballs. They make the air worth breathing.




Thanks, Lucy. I wish you had written this post before a recent Facebook controversy. Someone called Anne Carson —who won the 2026 Nobel Prize for Literature — pretentious. It was a matter of opinion, which literature, especially poetry, usually is.
The difference between a one-star and a five-star review is often subjective.