Skip to content

Top 5 Story Mistakes Even Good Writers Make


Good Writers CAN and DO Screw Up, Too

Good writers are everywhere, but that doesn’t mean they do everything perfectly.  B2W is known as a blog that recognises it’s probably easier to figure out what NOT to do as a writer … So it’s no accident my ‘Top 5 Mistakes’ series is so popular!

From craft issues and loglines, through to female characters, research and more, I’ve been trying to outline the numerous ways we COULD trip up. Here’s the top 5 story mistakes even GOOD writers make … Recognise any of these?? GOGOGO:

1) Not planning or outlining beforehand

Look, I realise some of us good writers are naturally blessed when it comes to structure in novels and screenplays. There really ARE some lucky writers out there for which this stuff apparently falls into place relatively easily. And good for them.

But ninety, maybe even ninety-five per cent of writers AREN’T like this – yes, even pro writers! It’s this 95% who could benefit from an outline and/or planning in advance. An outline or *some sort of plan* means these good writers don’t tie themselves up in knots … And yes, the actual draft gets written FASTER. True story! MORE: How To Write Screenplay Outlines, Beat Sheets & Treatments (psssssst — you can use them for novels too — I do!) 

2) Not understanding the importance of target audience

There’s this weird knee-jerk reaction amongst even good writers every time you say the word ‘audience’. So many roll their eyes and say ‘Well I’m not selling out!

Yet appreciating WHO your audience is not about ‘selling out’, but SELLING. No one says you have to throw all your passions and principles out of the window! In fact, it’s desirable to BE passionate and principled … and to know what you are doing.

So, if you don’t know *who* your target is, basically you DON’T know what you are doing. Your chances of hitting the BULLSEYE are much slimmer. Okay, not impossible, but it will be by accident instead of design. MORE: Why Writer Luck Is More Than Throwing Spaghetti At The Wall


3) Not doing enough research

I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve had conversations with good writers that basically rehash what we’ve already seen on TV, in movies, or in books. These could be whole storylines lifted wholesale … Or they might be elements.

Stock characters are a favourite, bringing forth under-developed, stereotypical ideas of people that feel really cheesy and even borderline offensive. Other things that may make an appearance can include WAYS of telling the story, ie. certain genres; non-linearity or other various plotting devices; or elements like montage, dream sequence or news exposition.

Note how all of the above relates to things we’ve already SEEN. This is yawnsome. The best, most memorable stories take something we recognise and TWISTS IT, whether it’s a story, a genre, a character, whatever. But crucially, writers simply cannot do this without finding out:

If you don’t do the above two steps, then you end up with something that feels RECYCLED and INAUTHENTIC. And guess what? That’s BORING! MORE: 15 Reasons Your Story SUCKS

4) Starting too early in the story

You HAVE to hit the ground running in your screenplay or novel. That doesn’t mean you have to have a prologue, or ‘rewind’ anything. You CAN introduce suspenseful, slow burn techniques. In short, you can do whatever you want … But the one thing you absolutely CANNOT DO is keep us waiting for the story to ‘start’. Many writers ‘introduce’ us to characters, THEN kick the story off … NoNoNoNoNoNoNoNo!!! Whatever story you’re telling, however you’re telling it, character and story must introduced TOGETHER. It’s the only way you can hit the ground running. MORE: Top 10 Tips For The Perfect Ten (Pages), plus 8 Ways To Jump Start Your Novel’s Description

5) Rushing the resolution

Endings that taper off, or conversely endings that are wrapped up in a little bow, are my pet PEEVES. However, neither of the these are bad craft or ‘wrong’. Good writers can do them WELL.

Me, I hate them. I prefer something that either makes me think (like an ambiguous ending, crucial difference) or an ending delivered with the subtlety of a sledgehammer to the FACE. I want something DELIVERED to me, either intellectually or emotionally. But if they float your boat, whatevs.

However, RUSHED endings can be a real story problem. Too often, it’s as if the screenwriter or novelists has suddenly gone, ‘Ooops! Better wrap this baby up!’ and whoooooooooooosh, they go through the motions of the resolution – bam-bam-bam. This doesn’t feel dramatically satisfying ‘cos the writer is literally ticking boxes to get it finished. Book.

Endings are so important. Don’t let your audience or reader down by skimping on them! MORE: How To Avoid A ‘B.O.S.H’ Screenplay

Good luck!

Want MORE Script Reading Secrets?

My course with LondonSWF, BREAKING INTO SCRIPT READING is perfect not only for wannabe script readers, but savvy writers who want to know how script readers work. Can you afford to miss out??

CLICK HERE for full details of the course, including feedback from past delegates. We expect it to sell out again, so act now to avoid disappointment. See you there!!!

Share this:

3 thoughts on “Top 5 Story Mistakes Even Good Writers Make”

  1. Hi Lucy – how about ‘mistakes’ post on choosing the wrong medium for a story. You know, film that should be TV, TV that’s crying out to be a novel… that kind of thing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *